Stone River Law – Criminal Defense Team

Can a Dismissed Domestic Violence Charge Be Expunged in Utah?

HERE FOR YOU WHEN IT MATTERS.

Yes, in most cases. A dismissed domestic violence charge can usually be expunged in Utah, but it doesn’t happen on its own. You have to apply, and prosecutors sometimes object, especially when the case involved a plea in abeyance. Here’s how it works.

Why a dismissed charge still matters

A dismissal ends the case, but it doesn’t erase the record. The arrest, the charge and the dismissal stay in court records and in the state’s criminal history database. They can show up on background checks for jobs, housing and professional licenses. A domestic violence allegation can raise questions even when the case went nowhere, and it can also cause problems in a firearm background check. The record also makes any future domestic violence charges enhanceable.

Why Utah’s Clean Slate law won’t clear it for you

Utah’s Clean Slate law automatically expunges many dismissed misdemeanor cases. Domestic violence cases are excluded, and so are cases that ended with a plea in abeyance for a domestic violence offense (Utah Code ยง 77-40a-205). To clear a dismissed domestic violence charge, you need to file a petition.

When you’re eligible

Under Utah Code ยง 77-40a-302, you can apply to expunge the records of an arrest or charge that didn’t result in a conviction when:

  • at least 30 days have passed since the arrest or charge, and
  • one of these is true:
    • all charges were dismissed with prejudice
    • a charge was dismissed without prejudice, and either the prosecutor consents in writing or at least 180 days have passed since the dismissal
    • you were acquitted of all charges at trial
    • prosecutors decided not to file charges
    • the statute of limitations has run on all charges

You aren’t eligible while another criminal case or plea in abeyance is pending against you, while you’re on probation, on parole or incarcerated for anything more than a minor offense, or while a criminal protective order or stalking injunction from the case is in effect.

If your case was dismissed after you completed a plea in abeyance, check the dismissal order to see whether it was dismissed with or without prejudice. That affects when you can apply.

The plea in abeyance issue

This is where dismissed domestic violence cases get complicated. Utah’s domestic violence enhancement statute (Utah Code ยง 77-36-1.1) treats an accepted plea in abeyance as a conviction when deciding whether to raise the penalty for a later domestic violence charge, even if the case was later dismissed. That look-back period is 10 years, or five years for a property damage offense.

Because of that, some prosecutors object to expunging a dismissed domestic violence case, arguing that the record needs to stay available in case of a future charge. The eligibility rules for dismissed cases don’t list a domestic violence plea in abeyance as a reason to deny expungement, and courts can grant it over the prosecution’s objection. The outcome still depends on the court and the facts of your case, which is why this kind of petition benefits from a lawyer.

How the process works

  1. Apply for a certificate of eligibility from the Utah Bureau of Criminal Identification. The bureau checks your record and charges an application fee.
  2. File a petition with the court where the case was handled, along with the certificate.
  3. The prosecutor is notified and can object. If there’s an objection, the court may hold a hearing.
  4. The court rules. If it grants the petition, it issues an order of expungement, and the records are sealed from public view.

A recent result

In a recent case, our client’s domestic violence charge had been dismissed after the client completed a plea in abeyance. When the client petitioned for expungement, the prosecutor’s office objected, arguing that Utah’s domestic violence enhancement statutes barred it. Attorney Bradley Henderson responded, and the court granted the expungement. See more of our results.

Every case depends on its own facts and law. Past results don’t guarantee the outcome of another case.

Talk with a Utah expungement attorney

If a dismissed domestic violence charge is still showing up on your record, we can review your case, confirm when you’re eligible and handle the petition, including any objection. Call Stone River Law at 801-448-7451. Our office is in Layton, and we help clients throughout Utah.

FAQ

Is a dismissed domestic violence charge automatically expunged in Utah?

No. Utah’s Clean Slate law excludes domestic violence cases, so you need to apply for a certificate of eligibility and petition the court.

How soon can I expunge a dismissed domestic violence charge?

If the charge was dismissed with prejudice, you can apply once 30 days have passed since the arrest or charge. If it was dismissed without prejudice, you need the prosecutor’s written consent or must wait 180 days after the dismissal.

Can the prosecutor object to my expungement?

Yes. Prosecutors sometimes object in domestic violence cases that ended with a plea in abeyance, citing the enhancement statute. The court decides whether to grant the expungement, and an objection doesn’t automatically mean it will be denied.

Does a dismissed plea in abeyance count as a conviction?

Not for most purposes. But Utah’s domestic violence enhancement statute treats an accepted plea in abeyance as a conviction when deciding the penalty for a later domestic violence charge within 10 years, even if the case was dismissed.

Do I need a lawyer to expunge a dismissed charge?

You can file on your own, but a lawyer helps when the prosecutor is likely to object or when your record has more than one case.


Secret Link