Utah’s justice courts are restricted to handling misdemeanors at the class B or class C level, plus infractions. Any class A misdemeanor or felony charge must be filed in district court. Many justice courts are restricted to only hearing cases arising within their own city borders. Some counties have county-wide justice courts, but these courts normally only handle cases coming from unincorporated areas of the county or from cities that do now have their own justice court.
Penalties in Justice Court
Although they are restricted to hearing only lower-level criminal cases, the penalties and punishments imposed in justice court can still be substantial.
- Class B Misdemeanors are mid-level misdemeanors, but are the highest category of crimes that can be handled in a justice court. The maximum penalty for a single class B misdemeanor conviction is 180 days jail and a fine of up to $1,000 plus surcharges. Class B misdemeanors commonly filed in justice courts include DUI, drug paraphernalia, assault, criminal mischief, possession of alcohol by a minor, and retail theft.
- Class C Misdemeanors are the lowest level misdemeanor under Utah law. They carry a maximum penalty of 90 days in jail and a fine of $750 plus surcharges.
Collateral consequences of a conviction can sometimes be more substantial than the actual penalty imposed by a justice court judge. A domestic violence conviction can restrict firearms rights. A DUI conviction can result in driver license suspensions. Other convictions may impact professional licensing – both getting a license and keeping a license.
Justice v. District – Court Differences
A major difference between Utah’s two court systems is the level of the offenses and the potential severity of the penalties. District courts in Utah are have general jurisdiction, and can handle the most serious felony charges with potential penalties that can include life in prison. Justice courts are restricted to misdemeanor-level criminal charges.
A significant, but sometimes overlooked, difference between justice and district court systems is the form and process of appealing the decision of a justice court judge. Because they are not considered to be “courts of record” under Utah law, an appeal a decision, ruling, or verdict from a justice court commonly involves a “de novo” hearing or trial, where the issue, motion, or even entire jury trial is heard over again in the district court, without consideration of the decision made by the original judge.