Navigating Police Interactions

Police encounters often seem straightforward, but they’re shaped by miscommunication and bias, which can lead to serious consequences. Understanding these dynamics is crucial for protecting your rights if you’re facing criminal charges. Clear communication and knowing your legal options can make all the difference in these situations.
attorney meeting with client at desk

What We Get Wrong

When we think about encounters with police officers, we often assume both sides are communicating clearly. But, the reality is more complicated. These interactions are shaped by miscommunication and bias, which can have serious consequences. Understanding how these dynamics play out can make a huge difference when it comes to protecting your rights if you’re facing criminal charges.

Why Trust Can Be Misleading

We think we can read other people’s intentions just by observing them. This becomes especially tricky during encounters with the police. For example, if an officer stops you, you might assume that your nervousness is apparent and that the officer can tell you’re just anxious. But to the officer, this nervous behavior can easily be misinterpreted as guilt or suspicious activity. Both of you are assuming you’re being understood, but really, you’re speaking two different languages. Misunderstandings like this are common in criminal cases.

Officers are trained to spot behaviors that might signal danger, but people sometimes behave differently under stress. Something as simple as a shaky voice or avoiding eye contact can be misread as guilt when it’s really just anxiety. In these moments, it’s crucial to remember that police officers are trained to read behaviors quickly, but human behavior under stress isn’t always easy to interpret. What’s meant as cooperation could look like resistance, and a simple misunderstanding can escalate into something far more serious.

When Bias Comes Into Play

Once someone—whether it’s an officer or a civilian—makes a decision or a judgment, the brain has a way of doubling down on it, even if it is wrong. When an officer makes a snap decision—like assuming someone is hiding something because they seem nervous—their brain works to justify that decision, even if it is wrong. In criminal cases, this can lead to officers doubling down on their initial judgment, making it difficult for them to admit a mistake or de-escalate the situation. This is how a minor interaction can spiral into an arrest or criminal charges.

For someone facing criminal accusations, this bias can complicate the case. It can make challenging the officer’s account of events harder, even if the original interaction was based on a misunderstanding or misreading behavior.

Why This Matters

Miscommunication and bias don’t just lead to uncomfortable moments—they can result in life-altering consequences, particularly in criminal cases. For people facing charges, especially those from marginalized communities, understanding how these dynamics work can provide an essential layer of protection during police encounters. Staying calm, knowing your rights, and understanding how your behavior might be interpreted can make a significant difference in these situations.

If you’re stopped by the police, knowing your rights—like the right to remain silent and the right to an attorney—is crucial.

Knowledge is Power

The more we understand how miscommunication and bias play out in these moments, the more control we have over the situation. Police officers can benefit from training that helps them recognize these biases, and individuals can protect themselves by being aware of how their behavior might be perceived. At the end of the day, both sides need to be mindful of these dynamics to make interactions safer for everyone.

How We Can Help You

At Stone River Law, we focus exclusively on criminal defense. We understand how quickly things can go wrong during a police encounter, and we’re here to help you navigate the legal system if you’re facing criminal charges. Whether it’s a misunderstanding during a traffic stop or a more serious situation, our team is dedicated to protecting your rights and providing the best possible defense.

If you or someone you know has had an encounter with law enforcement that escalated into criminal charges, contact us for a consultation. We’ll help you understand your legal options and work with you every step of the way to ensure you’re treated fairly under the law.

Originally Published: September 27, 2024

Related Articles

Who are our clients?
First and foremost, we see every client as a human being. While the criminal justice system uses labels like suspect, defendant, arrestee, victim,...
October 9, 2024
Effects of an Expungement Order in Utah
Utah Code section 77-40a-401 controls what happens once an expungement order has been signed by the court. It sets out rules for distribution of the...
October 9, 2024
What You Need to Know About Miranda Rights in Utah
One of the most well-known legal protections in the U.S. are the Miranda Rights. These rights, created by the U.S. Supreme Court in Miranda v....
October 9, 2024

Ready to explore our other articles?