What is the difference between acquittal and a not guilty verdict?

Under Utah law, an “acquittal” and a “not guilty” verdict have essentially the same meaning. But neither of these terms is a declaration that the defendant is factually innocent. The criminal justice system relies on a presumption of innocence at trial, with the government prosecutor carrying the burden of proving…
attorney meeting with client at desk

Under Utah law, an “acquittal” and a “not guilty” verdict have essentially the same meaning. But neither of these terms is a declaration that the defendant is factually innocent.

The criminal justice system relies on a presumption of innocence at trial, with the government prosecutor carrying the burden of proving each element of the offense. The burden of proof in a criminal trial requires that the jury be unanimously convinced, beyond a reasonable doubt, that the defendant did in fact commit the crime charged in the case.

Utah judges regularly instruct jurors, prior to beginning their deliberations, that they must be unanimous in whatever verdict they reach — either guilty or not guilty. Jurors are also instructed that the defendant does not have to prove actual innocence in order for the jury to reach a unanimous not guilty verdict.

A jury may be convinced that the defendant committed the crime charged, but still reach a not guilty verdict. Jurors may believe that the defendant committed the crime, but still have reasonable doubts as to the certainty of that belief.

In a civil trial, the burden of proof normally requires only a preponderance of the evidence — meaning that the jury be persuaded that one set of facts is more likely true than the other set of facts. In a criminal trial, a “more likely than not” standard is not sufficiently certain. Jurors must be convinced beyond a reasonable doubt.

Because of the burden of proof and reasonable doubt standards required in a criminal jury trial, neither an acquittal nor a not guilty verdict is a determination of actual innocence.

Originally Published: November 20, 2023

How can we help you?

Call us at 801-448-7451, or use this contact form.

    Related Articles

    The Double-Edged Sword of Plea Bargains in Utah’s Justice System
    Plea bargains are the backbone of Utah’s criminal justice system. In a world where courtrooms are perpetually overcrowded, prosecutors are...
    December 6, 2024
    Failure to Disclose Identity
    We've all seen old World War II movies where German officers stop citizens and ask, "Your papers, please." But did you know "papers" referred to a...
    November 26, 2024
    A Culture of Advocacy
    What Does It Mean That Our Firm Fosters a Culture of Advocacy? At Stone River Law, fostering a culture of advocacy is at the core of our mission....
    November 22, 2024

    Ready to explore our other articles?