Dismissed With Prejudice vs. Dismissed Without Prejudice in Utah Criminal Cases

Posted by Stone River Criminal Defense Team

Last Updated: March 20, 2025

When a criminal case in Utah is dismissed, it can be either with prejudice or without prejudice. The difference determines whether the charges can be refiled and what impact the dismissal can have on expungement.
attorney meeting with client at desk

What Does “Dismissed With Prejudice” Mean?

When a case is dismissed with prejudice, it’s closed for good. The prosecution cannot refile the same charges later. This usually happens when:

  • The court rules there isn’t enough evidence.
  • Prosecutors violate your rights (like withholding evidence).
  • You successfully complete a plea in abeyance agreement.
  • The statute of limitations runs out.

Common Situations for Dismissal With Prejudice

  • Plea in Abeyance: You agree to certain conditions—like probation or community service—in exchange for a dismissal. Once you complete them, the case is dismissed with prejudice, so it can’t be reopened.
  • Plea Deals: Prosecutors might drop some charges if you plead guilty to others. If a charge is dismissed as part of the deal, it’s usually dismissed with prejudice, meaning it’s gone for good.

How It Affects Expungement

If your criminal case was dismissed with prejudice, you can typically apply for expungement immediately, as long as there are no pending charges against you. If your case involved a plea in abeyance, you must wait at least 30 days after the dismissal before applying.

What Does “Dismissed Without Prejudice” Mean?

A dismissal without prejudice means the charges can be refiled later. This happens when:

  • Lack of Evidence (For Now): Prosecutors might drop the case if they don’t have enough proof, but if new evidence comes up, they can refile.
  • Clerical or Procedural Mistakes: If there’s a legal error—like filing the case in the wrong court—the judge might dismiss it without prejudice so it can be fixed and refiled.

How It Affects Expungement

A case dismissed without prejudice is not automatically eligible for expungement because prosecutors can still refile it. YIf your case was dismissed without prejudice, you must wait until the statute of limitations has expired or get the prosecutor to agree/stipulate to expunging the record before you can seek expungement.

What Happens Next?

Need help figuring out what your dismissal means? An experienced and skilled criminal defense attorney can guide you on next steps, including whether you qualify for expungement.

Originally Published: March 12, 2025

How can we help you?

Call us at 801-448-7451, or use this contact form.

    Related Articles

    Violent Felony – Gun Rights Restrictions
    Under Utah law, a person is classified as a “Category I” restricted person for purposes of firearm possession, gun rights, and possession...
    May 19, 2025
    Carter v. State, 2025 UT 13
    The Utah Supreme Court has unanimously affirmed a district court’s decision to vacate the conviction and death sentence of Douglas Stewart Carter,...
    May 16, 2025
    State v. Burton, 800 P.2d 817 (Utah Ct. App. 1990)
    In State v. Burton, 800 P.2d 817 (Utah Ct. App. 1990), the Utah Court of Appeals addressed a rare attempt to stretch criminal theft law into the...
    May 16, 2025

    Ready to explore our other articles?